438 listers have NOT amalgamated Steppe Grey Shrike into GGS yet?

Start
Prev
1
Next
End

09 Jun 2019 20:03 #1569 by Nick Moss

438 listers have NOT amalgamated Steppe Grey Shrike into GGS yet? was created by Nick Moss

Including moi (:-

But should this be mandatory?

Or am I missing something? Has it not been lumped into the Great Grey Shrike complex as a sub-species?

Please Log in to join the conversation.

Nick Moss
Topic Author
Offline

10 Jun 2019 03:05 #1570 by Mike Prince

Replied by Mike Prince on topic 438 listers have NOT amalgamated Steppe Grey Shrike into GGS yet?

Assuming you mean on BOU lists? The BOURC have not yet published taxonomic changes arising from the IOC January 2019 updates, and hence still treat Steppe Grey Shrike as a full species on the https://www.bou.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/British-List-2019-02-01.pdf .

Whilst we pre-empt changes to lists for new species occurrences, removing them later if not accepted, we have always waited for official confirmation of taxonomic changes. Since the BOURC do now follow IOC in taxonomic matters we could adopt any IOC changes for the British list as soon as IOC publish them instead of waiting for the BOURC's typically annual update. What do people think about this?

Cheers
-- Mike --

Want a signature like this?

Please Log in to join the conversation.

Mike Prince
Away

10 Jun 2019 06:36 #1571 by Nick Moss

Replied by Nick Moss on topic 438 listers have NOT amalgamated Steppe Grey Shrike into GGS yet?

Thanks for explaining the rational to me Mike, I understand now.

Not sure what others think, it's a difficult one, I'm surprised BOURC have not announced this lumping yet, we are 5 months on, but surely inevitable soon.

My post wasn't intended to be critical of BUBO BTW, its quite superb and fulfils my listing objectives perfectly - so thank you.

Anyway, I don't have strong views either way on this, may as well wait til BOURC officially announce it.

Please Log in to join the conversation.

Nick Moss
Topic Author
Offline

26 Sep 2019 20:00 #1610 by Brett Richards

Replied by Brett Richards on topic 438 listers have NOT amalgamated Steppe Grey Shrike into GGS yet?

I would prefer it if IOC changes were adopted by Bubo as soon as they are announced, rather than wait for BOU.

cheers

Brett

Please Log in to join the conversation.

Brett Richards
Offline

20 Oct 2019 16:18 #1617 by Jeremy Hurley

Replied by Jeremy Hurley on topic 438 listers have NOT amalgamated Steppe Grey Shrike into GGS yet?

I alluded to this very issue way back in January of this year, shortly after the IOC adopted the
"lumping" of Steppe Grey Shrike back into the Great Grey Shrike complex (version 9.1).

Please Log in to join the conversation.

Jeremy Hurley
Offline

31 Oct 2019 13:01 #1624 by Pete Hines

Replied by Pete Hines on topic 438 listers have NOT amalgamated Steppe Grey Shrike into GGS yet?

The British & Irish List BOU/IRBC does not include Steppe Grey Shrike (Lanius pallidostris) but Southern Grey Shrike (Lanius meridionalis) instead. A tad confusing.

Please Log in to join the conversation.

Pete Hines
Offline

04 Nov 2019 15:49 #1630 by Andy Musgrove

Replied by Andy Musgrove on topic 438 listers have NOT amalgamated Steppe Grey Shrike into GGS yet?

OK, now sorted

Please Log in to join the conversation.

Andy Musgrove
Offline

21 Dec 2019 08:17 #1665 by Nick Moss

Replied by Nick Moss on topic 438 listers have NOT amalgamated Steppe Grey Shrike into GGS yet?

BOURC have now amalgamated Steppe Grey Shrike into Great Grey Shrike so unfortunately Steppe Grey Shrike needs to go.

Please Log in to join the conversation.

Nick Moss
Topic Author
Offline

21 Dec 2019 11:54 #1668 by Andy Musgrove

Replied by Andy Musgrove on topic 438 listers have NOT amalgamated Steppe Grey Shrike into GGS yet?

Right - Steppe Shrike now lumped with Great Grey Shrike, so it should have disappeared from the checklists (BOU and B&I) and individual list totals. Let me know if you see anything not right as a result.

Wouldn't be surprised if it reappears in future!

Please Log in to join the conversation.

Andy Musgrove
Offline

22 Dec 2019 17:12 #1671 by William Bishop

Replied by William Bishop on topic 438 listers have NOT amalgamated Steppe Grey Shrike into GGS yet?

The totals page and headline total on Britain BOU are now wrong looking at my list. With Steppe Grey gone there appears to be 1 less bird on my list than on my total. So I don't think the total altered when it came off.

Please Log in to join the conversation.